Introduction
rumenGP implements a collection of nonlinear models for describing cumulative gas production during in vitro rumen fermentation.
This vignette summarizes:
- Model equations
- Parameter definitions
- Biological interpretation
- Advantages
- Limitations
- Typical applications
Throughout this vignette:
represents cumulative gas production at time:
Single-Pool Models
Brody
Ørskov and McDonald
Gompertz
Mitscherlich
LE0 (Logistic-Exponential Without Lag)
LEL (Logistic-Exponential With Lag)
Generalized Michaelis-Menten
Parameters
| Parameter | Description |
|---|---|
| A | Asymptotic gas production |
| K | Half-time parameter |
| c | Shape parameter |
Groot
Log-Logistic
Parameters
| Parameter | Description |
|---|---|
| A | Asymptotic gas production |
| r | Rate parameter (1/half-time) |
| a | Shape parameter |
Burr XII
Parameters
| Parameter | Description |
|---|---|
| VF | Asymptotic gas production |
| r | Rate parameter |
| a | Shape parameter |
| p | Shape parameter |
Interpretation
The Burr XII model is a highly flexible sigmoidal model capable of describing a broad range of fermentation profiles.
The parameter controls gas-production rate, while and jointly influence curve shape, asymmetry, and inflection behavior.
Advantages
- Highly flexible curve shape
- Accommodates diverse fermentation profiles
- Often provides excellent goodness of fit
- Useful for broad model comparison studies
Limitations
- More parameters than simpler models
- Greater risk of overfitting
- Parameter interpretation may be less intuitive
Inverse Paralogistic
Interpretation
The Inverse Paralogistic model is a flexible sigmoidal model capable of describing a wide range of cumulative gas-production curves.
The parameter controls production speed, while controls curve shape and steepness.
Advantages
- Flexible sigmoidal behavior
- Relatively simple parameterization
- Performs well across diverse gas-production datasets
Limitations
- Less common in rumen literature
- Shape parameter can be difficult to interpret biologically
- Requires strictly positive incubation times
Multi-Pool Models
Dual Logistic
Model Equivalence
Groot and Generalized Michaelis-Menten
The Groot and generalized Michaelis-Menten models are mathematically equivalent for positive values of time.
Parameter correspondence:
VF = Ab = Kk = c
Both formulations describe the same underlying sigmoidal gas production curve but differ in parameterization.
The Groot model contains the term
and is therefore undefined at
.
Consequently, observations collected at Time_h = 0 are
excluded when fitting the Groot model.
Researchers may choose either formulation depending on the terminology commonly used in their field.
Groot, Generalized Michaelis-Menten, and Log-logistic
The Log-logistic formulation
can be rewritten as
which is mathematically equivalent to both the Groot and generalized Michaelis-Menten models for positive values of time.
Parameter correspondence:
| Groot | Generalized Michaelis-Menten | Log-logistic |
|---|---|---|
| VF | A | VF |
| b | K | 1/r |
| k | c | a |
Therefore, the Groot, Generalized Michaelis-Menten, and Log-logistic models represent mathematically equivalent parameterizations of the same underlying sigmoidal gas production curve.
These formulations differ only in how their parameters are expressed.
Unlike the Groot model, the generalized Michaelis-Menten and Log-logistic formulations are mathematically defined at and therefore retain the initial observation during model fitting.
Consequently, parameter estimates and goodness-of-fit statistics may differ slightly among parameterizations when time-zero observations are present.
rumenGP implements all three parameterizations, allowing researchers to choose the formulation that is most familiar within their field while recognizing their underlying mathematical equivalence.
Choosing a Model
A practical progression is:
Simple Models
- EXP0
- Brody
- Ørskov and McDonald
Use when:
- Data show monotonic behavior
- Lag is negligible
- Simplicity is preferred
Lag Models
- EXPL
- Logistic
- Gompertz
- Mitscherlich
Use when:
- A lag phase is biologically expected
- Initial microbial adaptation is important
Flexible Sigmoidal Models
- LE0
- LEL
- Groot
- Generalized Michaelis-Menten
- Burr XII
- Inverse Paralogistic
- Log-logistic
Use when:
- Fermentation profiles display sigmoidal behavior
- Greater flexibility is needed
- Multiple biologically plausible models are being compared
- Information-criterion-based selection (AIC or BIC) is desired
Multi-Pool Models
- Dual Logistic
Use when:
- Fast and slow fermenting fractions are expected
- Substrate heterogeneity is important
Custom Models
Researchers can also define their own equations using:
See:
vignette("custom-models")for additional details.
Model Selection Guidance
No single gas-production model should be considered universally superior.
Model performance depends on:
- Feed type
- Experimental design
- Data quality
- Fermentation profile characteristics
- Model-selection criteria
A practical workflow is:
- Fit several biologically plausible candidate models.
- Verify convergence.
- Examine fitted curves visually.
- Examine residual patterns.
- Compare RMSE.
- Compare AIC and BIC.
- Evaluate parameter plausibility.
- Select the model most appropriate